Arousal
of Empathy and Aggression
K. Obuchi |
In
this review we examined effects of situational and personality factors
of empathy upon aggressive behavior. Empathy was defined as consisting
of cognitive (perspective-taking) and affective components (sympathy).
It was hypothesized that these two components are evoked independently
of each other. Understanding of other's suffering does not always
lead to sympathy, but may sometimes lead to sadistic reactions. A
number of studies were reviewed in which empathy was situationally
aroused by exposure to pain cues, perceived similarity, and self-diclosure
by a victim. The effects of these factors upon aggression were not
consistent. For example, pain cues reduced aggression in nonangered
subjects while sometimes escalated aggression in angered subjects.
These results suggest that pain cues, similarity, and self-disclosure
facilitate perspective-taking but do not determine emotional responses.
What determines emotional reactions is the type of motives involved
in aggressive behaivor. When an aggressor is motivated by hostile
motives (the goal is to harm a victim), the situationally enhanced
perspective taking is likely to lead more aggression. When he/she
is motivated by nonhostile motives (the goal is other than to harm
the victim), however, the enhanced perspective taking is likely to
lead less aggression. Lastly, empathy as a personality trait was
proposed as being differentially responsive to empathy-arousing stimuli,
emphasizing the interaction effects upon aggression of personality
and situational factors in arousal of empathy.
|