Pragmatic
Determinants of Children's Responses to the Wason Selection Task
O. Frydman, P. Light & J. Alegria |
A
pilot study and two experiments are reported in which thematic versions
of the Wason Selection Task were used to assess children's conditional
reasoning. The pilot and first experiment each involved 100 eleven
year olds, while the second experiment involved 36 eight year olds
and 36 ten year olds. Results of the pilot suggested that 11 year
olds can perform well on the full Selection Task, provided that the
rules take the form of justified permissions or obligations. The
first experiment confirmed this, with some of the error patterns
on non justified rules being interpretable in terms of children's
spontaneous judgements of costs and benefits. The second experiment
established that even eight year olds can perform well with appropriate
thematic versions of the Selection Task. These findings are discussed
in relation to theories of contextually moderated formal competences,
social contracts and pragmatic schemas, and are held to be most consistent
with pragmatic schema theory. Key words: reasoning, deduction, Wason Selection Task, pragmatic schemas |