Acoustic
and Visual Confusions in Immediate Memory in Japanese and English
Speakers
M. Flaherty & A. Moran |
Phonological
coding plays a major role in the identification of words in English.
But to what extent is access to phonology for words written in logographic
Japanese Kanji mediated by access to their meaning? This study set
out to answer this question in a memory task with homophones and
visually similar words. The effects of both homophony and visual
similarity were obtained under conditions of the "selective
interference" paradigm, designed to investigate the involvement
of the articulatory control system and visual recall in memory. Both
native English (n = 80) and Japanese (n = 72) speakers, readers of
fundamentally different orthographies, were examined. The patterns
of interference suggest that the memory strategies employed with
both English words and Kanji are characterized by similar strategies.
In particular, phonologically similar words caused more confusion
than visually similar words. Articulatory suppression caused much
interference in memory span in both language groups. The results
support the universal phonological principle, which predicts automatic
activation of phonological information in all languages. Key words: English, Kanji, phonological similarity, visual similarity, articulatory suppression |